Free calculator
Disability Insurance Calculator for Nurses and Healthcare Workers
What your group plan would put in your bank account each month if you couldn’t work, and how big the gap is.
A group long-term disability plan advertises a percentage, usually 60%. What you’d actually receive depends on three things the brochure doesn’t lead with: which pay the plan counts, the monthly cap, and whether the benefit is taxed. Pick your job to start from an example, then put in the numbers from your benefits summary. Nothing you enter leaves this page.
Tax rate and coverage limit
Your average federal and state rate while living on the benefit. It’s usually lower than today’s, because the benefit replaces only part of your pay.
Insurers cap group plus individual coverage at a share of earned income. Their real tables vary.
Most plans start paying only after a waiting period, often 90 days. Your emergency fund covers that stretch.
How to read your result
The shortfall is what you’d still be short each month once benefits start, after the cap, taxes and any other income that keeps coming in. If it’s close to zero, your coverage matches your spending on paper. If it’s large, you have three levers: an individual policy, a bigger emergency fund, or a lower fixed budget.
The share of pay replaced is the group benefit you’d keep, as a share of everything you earn today before tax. A “60% plan” often lands well below 60% once overtime and differentials drop out and the benefit is taxed. On high pay the cap does most of the damage: with a $6,100 cap, a CRNA earning the median $236,590 gets about 31% of base pay before tax.
My take: if the gap is more than a few hundred dollars a month and someone depends on your paycheck, get an individual quote while you’re healthy. Price is only half of it. Read how the policy defines disability before you compare premiums. More on that in protect your income first.
What this calculator assumes
- The group benefit is the percentage times the pay your plan counts, divided by 12, then cut to the monthly cap. By default only base pay counts. Check the box if your plan’s definition of earnings includes overtime, differentials or bonuses. Pay from another employer or 1099 work never counts toward this employer’s plan.
- Taxes: under IRS rules, benefits from a plan your employer paid for, or one you paid for with pre-tax dollars, are taxable income. Benefits from a policy you paid for with after-tax dollars aren’t. If you and your employer split the premium, part of the benefit is taxable; this calculator treats it as all one or the other. Taxable benefits are cut by the single rate you enter (10% by default). It doesn’t work out brackets, state rules, or the Social Security and Medicare tax that can apply to the first months of employer-paid disability pay. Tax rules as of October 2026.
- No offsets: many group plans subtract Social Security disability, workers’ compensation or state disability benefits from what they pay, so the real group benefit can be lower than shown.
- Not modeled: the waiting period, cost-of-living increases, partial benefits if you can work some, and the definition of disability. For a nurse whose injury ends bedside work but not desk work, that definition decides whether a policy pays at all.
- The coverage limit is one flat percentage of all your earned income. Insurers use their own tables, count your group plan against them and treat 1099 income their own way. Treat the room it shows as a question for an insurance agent, not a quote.
FAQ
Why does a 60% disability plan pay less than 60% of my pay?
Three things shrink it. Many plans count only base pay, so overtime, shift differentials and bonuses drop out. A monthly cap limits the benefit on higher pay. And if your employer pays the premium, the benefit is taxable, so you keep less than the check.
Are long-term disability benefits taxable?
It depends on who paid the premium. Benefits from an employer-paid plan, or one you paid for with pre-tax dollars, are taxable income. Benefits from a policy you paid for with after-tax dollars are tax-free. If the cost was split, the part tied to your employer’s payments is taxable. These are the IRS rules as of October 2026.
Does my hospital’s disability plan cover PRN or agency shifts?
Usually not. An employer’s group plan covers pay from that employer, often just base pay. PRN shifts for another employer, agency work and 1099 gig-app shifts fall outside it. An individual policy can often count that income, within each insurer’s rules.
How much individual disability insurance can I buy?
Insurers limit group and individual coverage combined to a share of your earned income, using their own tables. The limit in this calculator is a placeholder for those tables. An independent agent can quote the real limit from several insurers at once.
What is the waiting period on disability insurance?
It’s the stretch between when you stop working and when benefits start, also called the elimination period. Ninety days is common for long-term disability. Short-term disability or an emergency fund of three to six months of spending has to cover that gap.
Keep going
Sources (checked October 2026)
- Taxes: IRS, life insurance and disability insurance proceeds FAQ; IRS Publication 525, sickness and injury benefits; IRS Publication 15-A (third-party sick pay).
- Typical group plan: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Beyond the Numbers, disability insurance plans. Example cap: a city employer’s Mutual of Omaha long-term disability summary ($6,100 a month).
- Pay: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025 medians. BLS annual wages leave out overtime and shift differentials.
I’m an emergency physician, not a financial advisor, insurance agent, CPA or attorney. This calculator is an educational estimate, not tax, legal or insurance advice, and not a recommendation of any insurer or policy. Plan terms vary; read your own plan documents and talk to a professional before buying or changing coverage.